I came to the series a
lot later than most of the bloggers I've seen. As such, many of the early books
were already written, and I never really questioned a lot about the order.
There were already several super specials and I think I started reading right
around when the first mystery came out. (I definitely bought #3, Mallory and
the Ghost Cat, when it was brand new.)
But back when I was
trying to read all the books in order, I stopped to think about the placement
of these books. I felt it was important to read them in order, especially
because they often refer back to other books, even the mysteries, that have
already happened. The worst example of this, for me, was how they kept
mentioning that MA had been in counseling. I had read every book, 1-64 at least
part way through and had read almost every book after that, up to 73. (I still
have not read #65. We'll see...) I had seen several references to MA being in
counseling but never the book it originally came from. Turns out (and I
discovered this about six months ago) that it never really happened in a book;
the first reference to it actually comes from the BSC chain letter book my mom
wouldn't buy me because it was too expensive. It's the secret MA tells Claudia
that no one else knows.
Anyway, my sister was making fun of me for
having a BSC blog and I was telling her how I couldn't find SS #1, and how I
had to read it before I could go on to #10. Why? Because it takes place in
summer vacation, before Stacey leaves for NY and Mallory and Jessi join the
club. Since school starts in #10, it must occur before then. It also has to be
after #8, since it references how MA and Stacey were mother's helpers in the
events of that book.
What about the other
SSs? I have a few ideas.
#2--Between #24 and #26.
Because Emily has already been adopted and Mimi is still alive.
#3--Between #28 and #30.
Stacey's back but Richard and Sharon aren't married yet.
#4--Right before book
#36. Makes sense, because Aunt Cecelia is introduced in the former and moves in
with the family in the latter.
This becomes harder as
the books move on and fewer life-changing things happen. There's fewer changes
as the books go on and most of the ones that do happen involve Dawn moving back
and forth to California. You know, for example, that SS #12 happens when Dawn moves
back to Stoneybrook after her "six month" stay in Palo City, but I
honestly don't remember what exact book number in the regular books she
reappears in. It has to be between #77 (when Dawn is in Cali) and #84 (when
Dawn is in Stoneybrook.) Likewise, you know that SS #13 occurs after book #89,
when Abby arrives in town, because she's in that one.
I once found a post, I think on http://babysittersclub.livejournal.com/, that had them in order. I used that for my blog and it seemed to work for the most part. There were a few books that seemed to be reversed but it was a good guide!
ReplyDeleteDawn's first RS book back after her 'six month stay' in California is #81, Kristy and Mr. Mom.
ReplyDelete